Prozac debate: a personal view

ProzacAlthough the outcome is actually nothing new, a new study has concluded that Prozac is next to useless for those suffering with depression.

I’ve suffered from depression over the past few years and, on one occasion, I was prescribed Prozac.

Ironically enough, I didn’t realise that’s what I was taking, because the doctor who wrote the prescription used the non-brand name for the drug, fluoxetine.

I stayed on it around a year before deciding that my need for it was at an end.

Did it work? Well, that’s tough to say. Certainly my symptoms slowly receded and my mood lifted, but whether that was down to the drug or various other factors is impossible to ascertain.

What I found more interesting, and scary, was a recent visit to a new doctor.

I went to talk to him about possible ways to treat SAD and wondered what his views were.

I suggested St John’s Wort to him and his surprising riposte was something along the lines of: ‘Why not just take Prozac?’

Now this shocked me. My use of anti-depressants has tended to be as a last resort, assuming them to be of some benefit. I hate the fact that I am having to use a chemical to treat something, but accept that depression can often be a chemical imbalance that needs to be righted.

SAD, on the other hand, is seasonal and lasts a mere 3-4 months usually. The thought of popping Prozac as a way of stopping that appals me far more.

The fact that my (young and fairly clued up) doctor likened taking St John’s Wort, a naturally-occurring treatment, to Prozac makes me realise how willy-nilly the drug has been handed out.

Perhaps this new report will make my doctor and many others think twice before prescribing a seemingly useless, yet addictive drug.

4 thoughts on “Prozac debate: a personal view”

  1. I take St. John’s Wort in the winter and it’s a real rescue to me. It’s interesting that in German half of all prescription meds are for SJW and in the UK it’s viewed with suspicion.

    Nice post Rob.

  2. (as I was saying…)
    but not for short term problems. I admire you for writing about this; as I said on my blog, it’s a tough one for boys to admit to. Whenever I think of you, I always think of your lovely smile and sunny disposition,and I reckon that if people who didn’t know us met us, they’d never guess our black (dog) ‘secret’.

  3. You’re right Cliff. Although, to be honest, there is still a huge suspicion about lots of homeopathic remedies – some of which is probably justified, some of which is just stupidity.

    And thank you, Clair. I agree that often, the people who seem the most happy are often the ones with the darkest secrets.

    I think that people who talk about it (men or women) are often the ones who’ve achieved some sort of peace with the condition – it’s far more difficult when you’re in the middle of it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *